Vegan Baking Articles Vegan Baking Articles and Guides Sugar and Glycemic Index - Different Sweeteners Compared

Sugar and Glycemic Index - Different Sweeteners Compared Mattie

Written by Mattie    
0
Comments (2)
At Veganbaking.net we stress taste before healthiness when it comes to sweets. If you're into vegan baking you may be a health nut and sooner or later you may be concerned about how sugar effects the body. If you're a junk food vegan, we respect that. If you're concerned with the health aspects of different kinds of sugar, read on.

Sugar is basically poison or a drug and, like poisons or drugs, sometimes small amounts can be fun! What type of sweetener you ingest can make a small impact on your health. Every type of sugar has a negative effect on heath in large amounts whether it's agave syrup or high fructose corn syrup so this article is kind of nitpicky. Nevertheless, it's good to know what sweeteners make what impact on your blood sugar levels. Different sweeteners also have different densities of beneficial nutrients but the levels are too small to be of a substantial health benefit.

Glycemic Index or GI is the measurement in between 0 and 100 of how fast carbohydrates raise blood glucose levels. The faster carbohydrates break down and raise blood sugar, the higher the glycemic index. Low glycemic index foods are preferred because recent studies have shown that a diet involving high GI foods can increase the risk of diabetes, heart disease and obesity. Foods that have a GI of 70 or more are considered to be high.

Different sweeteners have different GI levels. Below is a chart to see where your favorite sweetener places on this scale.

Sweeteners and Glycemic Index

Sweetener Glycemic Index
Stevia <1***
Agave Syrup 11*
Fructose 22**
Brown Rice Syrup 25***
Barley Malt 42***
Maple Syrup 54*
Blackstrap Molasses 55***
Corn Syrup 75***
Turbinado Sugar 65***
White Sugar 80***
High Fructose Corn Syrup 87***
Glucose 100*

*These values are gathered from University of Sydney's Glycemic Index Database at www.glycemicindex.com
**These values are gathered from www.diabetesnet.com/diabetes_food_diet/glycemic_index.php
***These values are gathered from www.greenmagazines.com/organic/alternative-sugars.php

Note the high GI of high fructose corn syrup. As of this writing, an increasing number of prepared foods are including high fructose corn syrup due to it's affordability. Due to it's high GI most health professionals recommend reducing high fructose corn syrup intake as much as possible.

Keep in mind that regular white sugar tends to have the best flavor in baked goods because it's the most neutral. Using a sweetener other than what a recipe was designed to use usually results in compromising flavor in the baked item. Turbinado sugar isn't as high as refined sugar on the GI scale and tends to not 'color' your baked item's sweetness profile too excessively. It's used frequently in our kitchen.

If you have a sweet tooth it's a good idea to reduce excess high glycemic foods in your diet when convenient, get plenty of exercise and pay attention to protein intake to balance blood sugar levels. Remember that both sugar and moderation are best used in moderation.

Sugar by Uwe Hermann via Flickr
Lollipops by Dhammza via Flickr


Get a price on the Dry Measuring Cups I Recommend at Amazon.


Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported


User comments

Already have an account?
Other Info
Comments
Please enter the security code.
help me to stop eating sugar
Commented by antonis September 07, 2011

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

help me to stop eating sugar

You cited a blog with absolutely no sources itself for your glycemic index.
Commented by Anon June 07, 2011

You cited a blog with absolutely no sources itself for your glycemic index.

 
Powered by JReviews